Greatest of all time (GOAT NFL)

[Dmpsix]

Originally Posted by hrpiii

he also was forced to retire due to concussions, so I'm not putting a lot of stock in a guy that has head trauma. Maybe if Joe or Terry backed that up, maybe even Farve.. just Troy, by himself... nope.

Aikman's praise or not doesn't take away from Brady still being the greatest to ever do it, it's just more high praise from one of the better QB's of the 90s.

[3 SS's]

Originally Posted by hrpiii

he also was forced to retire due to concussions, so I'm not putting a lot of stock in a guy that has head trauma. Maybe if Joe or Terry backed that up, maybe even Farve.. just Troy, by himself... nope.

Lol, yeah....you need other guys to confirm for Troy because he had concussions, lol....I'm sure the others you mention never got knocked silly
I realize the eye test doesn't work for fans of other teams that Brady knocks around regularly, the bias blinds some. You should watch the Troy Aikman " A football life " it may shed a little more light for you on his reason for retirement.

[Kenny Camaro]

Originally Posted by hrpiii

he also was forced to retire due to concussions, so I'm not putting a lot of stock in a guy that has head trauma. Maybe if Joe or Terry backed that up, maybe even Farve.. just Troy, by himself... nope.

Terry stated in the post game that Tom Brady is "The greatest quarterback I have ever seen". So that's two out of four on your list. Uhh, Farve had quite a Vicodin addiction for quite sometime, soooo, I don't know how that rates with your concussion evaluation statement. Haven't heard anything from Joe on the subject.

[BMR Sales]

Originally Posted by hrpiii

he also was forced to retire due to concussions, so I'm not putting a lot of stock in a guy that has head trauma. Maybe if Joe or Terry backed that up, maybe even Farve.. just Troy, by himself... nope.

Terry was never the Brightest Bulb in the pack!

[Kenny Camaro]

Heard that Joe Montana is on record that Tom Brady is not the greatest of all time QB. He also said that he is not the GOAT either. He said that you can not compare players from different eras. For what it's worth, that's his opinion.

[Dmpsix]

Originally Posted by Kenny Camaro

Heard that Joe Montana is on record that Tom Brady is not the greatest of all time QB. He also said that he is not the GOAT either. He said that you can not compare players from different eras. For what it's worth, that's his opinion.

Yeah but his wife was quick to roll her eyes and say "Yeah right Joe we hear it all the time at home who the greatest was."

http://www.tmz.com/2017/02/10/joe-mo...y-greatest-qb/


Tom Brady is still the greatest to ever do, sure Joe Montana is perfect in Superbowls, but how many times has he been bumped out of the first round or lost playoff games? Dude is far from perfect as a QB like some people make him out to be.

[3 SS's]

Originally Posted by Dmpsix

Yeah but his wife was quick to roll her eyes and say "Yeah right Joe we hear it all the time at home who the greatest was."

http://www.tmz.com/2017/02/10/joe-mo...y-greatest-qb/


Tom Brady is still the greatest to ever do, sure Joe Montana is perfect in Superbowls, but how many times has he been bumped out of the first round or lost playoff games? Dude is far from perfect as a QB like some people make him out to be.

Lol, I heard that the other day....as far as Montana, you're spot on, he was 4-0 and that's a fact, but.....he had his same cast year in and year out, unlike Brady's revolving door of key position players.
Hell, Montana stepped away and Steve Young took them to a Superbowl victory, Montana must have been a "system QB"

[Kenny Camaro]

Originally Posted by 3 SS's

Lol, I heard that the other day....as far as Montana, you're spot on, he was 4-0 and that's a fact, but.....he had his same cast year in and year out, unlike Brady's revolving door of key position players.
Hell, Montana stepped away and Steve Young took them to a Superbowl victory, Montana must have been a "system QB"

Definately Montana was a system QB, west coast offense system. He had it down ,without a doubt. Why do people knock QB's as a 'system' QB? They become extremely proficant at a proven system and win, so people knock them for it. Every SuperBowl winning QB was useing 'their' system. They weren't drawing plays up in the dirt, were they?

[Joe M 2012 2SS]

Linebacker- Lawrence Taylor.

No player in the history of the NFL has struck fear in the hearts of the opposing offense like LT did.
This guy came at you like a freight train, no one could stop him.

[3 SS's]

Cocaine will do that

[Joe M 2012 2SS]

Originally Posted by 3 SS's

Cocaine will do that

Yes he did have a problem with that, after getting clean in 1986, he produced the best season for a linebacker in the history of the game.

[3 SS's]

LOL, yeah...he was clean in 86, 99% right

[Kenny Camaro]

Originally Posted by 3 SS's

LOL, yeah...he was clean in 86, 99% right

99.6%. Lol

[Chaotic73]

Originally Posted by 3 SS's

LOL, yeah...he was clean in 86, 99% right

Talk about the pot calling the kettle black, LOL. A Patriot fan bringing up the fact that someone try to get an edge by cheating. But don't dare accuse the Patriots of any wrong doings, they are squeaky clean.