Mafia #6 - Interesting!!! ONLY POST IF PLAYING!!!!!

[BowtieBelle]

what's shakin' guys?

Looks like I have some reading to do.

[Mindz]

Back to square one...

[Mr_Draco]

Originally Posted by acowherd

Care to elaborate??

I won't give out anything yet that will give out my role but I know without a doubt PMC is not mafia. And I will say I can not investigate so don't bother asking.

I am also pretty confident that insidethreat is the SK and as much as I would like to vote off the SK this early, I won't vote for someone who is kidnapped and can't speak up for themselves.

[OffseT]

vote nl
For now..

[acowherd]

Originally Posted by Maroboy2001

vote nl
For now..

Huh???

Why? On day 1 I can see, but after that, there should be someone to vote for!

[Mr_Draco]

Originally Posted by Mindz

Back to square one...

Personally I'm suspicious if Sim and acowherd. The way the last nl's needed all happened within a couple minutes when a little bit earlier they didn't know what to do.

vote Sim curly

[Bluestreak 2010]

Originally Posted by Mr_Draco

I won't give out anything yet that will give out my role but I know without a doubt PMC is not mafia. And I will say I can not investigate so don't bother asking.

I am also pretty confident that insidethreat is the SK and as much as I would like to vote off the SK this early, I won't vote for someone who is kidnapped and can't speak up for themselves.

Hmm. . . If this is true I think I know either your or PMC's role. I hope you're telling the truth.

After all the different possibilities I posted as to why insidethreat may not be the SK can you explain why you are so confident this early. I'm just curious because I have to admit I jumped the gun in voting for him before looking at all the possibilities.

[Mr_Draco]

Well first what we know.

There are two roleblockers in this game, the kidnapper and the mediator. Insidethreat was kidnapped.

There are three protectors in this game, mediator, white mage, and the gambler.

Now lets speculate.

I'm pretty sure the mediator had a vote registered at the end of the day so that means he couldn't have roleblocked or protected anyone leaving just one roleblocker last night, the kidnapper.

Now unless I missed a post there are 4 people who haven't posted yet on day 2. If someone who has posted was the SK's target and was protected by someone or was the protector, someone would have posted that by now so it's safe to assume that no one that has posted yet is either the SK's target or the protector of the SK's target. So if the SK attacked last night this means of the four people that hasn't posted yet, one must have been the intended target and one must have been the protector. The odds of this coincidence happening is very small and it is more likely that the SK was roleblocked last night by the kidnapper which would just so happen to be insidethreat. There are too many "what ifs" that must fall in place for insidethreat not to be the SK so to me this is the only logical choice.

[Overflow]

Hey guys. Sorry I've been out of the loop all weekend. Spent the night with a friend on friday then went to Monster Jam.

But I think I know who I'm voting for, for now.

VOTE SWAT

[Mr_Draco]

Originally Posted by Bluestreak 2010

After all the different possibilities I posted as to why insidethreat may not be the SK can you explain why you are so confident this early. I'm just curious because I have to admit I jumped the gun in voting for him before looking at all the possibilities.

Something else to keep in mind, both the mafia and the SK want the day phase to end as quick as possible and get to the night phase. Now look at the last three nl votes. They all happened within a couple minutes apart which to me indicates that all three was set up by the mafia though pm's or two of them is mafia and one is the SK. Insidethreat was the last vote needed which is typical SK. Log on, see that only one nl is needed to end the day so he votes nl. Combine this with what I posted earlier and that is too many coincidences for me to ignore.

[Mr_Draco]

Originally Posted by Overflow

Hey guys. Sorry I've been out of the loop all weekend. Spent the night with a friend on friday then went to Monster Jam.

But I think I know who I'm voting for, for now.

VOTE SWAT

Do you care to elaborate as to why?

[Overflow]

Originally Posted by Mr_Draco

Do you care to elaborate as to why?

Let's just say, my role allows me to see right through people.

[acowherd]

Originally Posted by Mr_Draco

Something else to keep in mind, both the mafia and the SK want the day phase to end as quick as possible and get to the night phase. Now look at the last three nl votes. They all happened within a couple minutes apart which to me indicates that all three was set up by the mafia though pm's or two of them is mafia and one is the SK. Insidethreat was the last vote needed which is typical SK. Log on, see that only one nl is needed to end the day so he votes nl. Combine this with what I posted earlier and that is too many coincidences for me to ignore.

I agree, but I originally voted NL...then PMC wanted to run the vote count up on someone and I unvoted and voted later.

[acowherd]

I'll go with overflow...but if swat turns out pro town we know we were hoodwinked.

Vote Swat