I vote remove the stripes and maybe even put another color like dark silver or even a black on your blue car would look good.
I have ZL1 style rims from Factory Reproductions. Fairly inexpensive. They have matt, satin, gloss, etc. I ended up going 1 inch wider than stock all the way around. I bought real ZL1 center caps off eBay so they'd have the Chevy bowtie. As long as you don't put on any ZL1 badging, hardly anyone will call you a poser for "faking" a ZL1 -- these are just the coolest rims for a Camaro out there! They totally changed the way my ride looks and I get a lot of compliments.