I've seen a number of Verts that don't have that problem. It didn't, however, appear that the owners lowered the top often.
I'd say go for it if you really are set on a vert. In my opinion a vert soft top is just fine with wear marks. It's to be expected. It's all about the top being down. At a car show or cruising around the top will be down anyway.
I see you live in Wisconsin. So you will have your top up a lot. I think the Camaro Vert looks terrible with the top up. I'd go with a hard top anyway.
But to answer your question I'd say if you are a vert kinda person (and I see by your sig you like to feel the wind) then I'd just get the vert. Again, the top is ugly with NO marks. Can't be that bad with marks.
Honestly, if I had to make no jokes and be serious I'd easily say Buffalo.
QB edge, Buffalo - Fitz has a few seasons in this system and is familiar with his recievers.
RB edge, Buffalo - Jackson can run between the tackles and Spiller has the speed. Bush is just a scat back guy.
WR edge, Buffalo - I've never heard of a single reciever on the Dolphins current starting line-up. lol
O line - Push
TE edge, Dolphins - But the Bills don't use the TE as much as I'd like.
Defense edge, Push - Lots of D line improvement and speed in the backfield for the Bills. We'll see if it helps, it is a big question mark.