Neither.. I bought an MRobe:100 when Olympus
link was cutting production and never looked back.. still runs though the battery is starting to fade out (only get about 5 hours out of it now)..
5Gb music only.. wtf do I need videos or pictures for .. its a damn music player.. and when will anyone ever need more than 5 GB? my entire CD collection is like 8 GB ripped at 128k.. when am i ever going to listen to ALL of it at one sitting? uh never.
Edit - When this dies I will go looking for another alternative .. because IPODS(and the entire apple/mac brand) are crap(experience with PCs/Servers for well over 20 years) and more of a fashion than function and a lot of other MP3 players out there just don't work as advertised.