This thread is amusing because it's full of internet experts.
I personally LOVE the fact there's close competition and the customer is winning. It's like Burger King, McDonald's and Wendy's going at it in the burger wars. Life's more fun when you have choices.
I try to keep an open mind, even though I'm from a GM family. Because of that, I'm sticking with Camaro. If Ford or Chrysler ever build anything that draws me away from the Camaro, I'd give it a whirl, but they haven't hit it yet. Ford and Chrysler pony cars have some features I find attractive, but as a package, there's things that I can't quite get past and are deal breakers to having one in my driveway. I drove an SRT, and a GT, but wasn't impressed enough. Camaro isn't perfect, but IMO, it's the best out of the 3 for me. I want Chrysler and Ford to up the ante and Camaro to respond, and vice-versa round the table. Otherwise, we'd all be driving vanilla cars.
But, with that said, you must ask yourself...WWJD? (What Would Jesus Drive?) If Jesus had a car, I'd bet it would be a Camaro.