Wow, thank you all for the suggestions. I've researched and priced out all of your suggestions and have decided Chevy is my best bet. The Malibu does indeed look like a nice car, but the price puts it out of the running. If I want that Camaro, the last thing I need is to have my expenses increase!
Basically I'm between the Cobalt and the Aveo. The Aveo I priced was about $650 cheaper and gets a little bit better gas milage (34 HWY to the Cobalt's 33), but if the Cobalt's as superior as it sounds like I may have to just look that way.
As I said before, I haven't decided on getting rid of the Corolla yet, I'm just researching my options so I can make the best choice. If I can trade it in for a Chevy and actually save money, I would be sold.
I know in an earlier thread we were talking about dealer costs VS MSRP, does anyone know where I could find this information in regards to the Cobalt and Aveo? Dragon, I know you're planning on grabbing a Cobalt pretty soon, what research have you done? If you don't mind sharing....