I know it's a haul from here in PA (it takes me about 7 hrs just to hit the state border when I go home), but if you want maximum relaxation and good hunting my vote is Maine. Even though you specified private property only, here's a couple of links if you want to expand your options. I'd offer my cabin up there, but it's so remote you'd never find it.
http://www.rosslakecamps.com/
http://maineguides.com/ (this has a link for hunting and places to stay)