Greatest of all time (GOAT NFL)

[Kenny Camaro]

I do believe Greene was better, the others are so close it's just personal preference, again, very good list. Being from the metro a Detroit area, I would have Barry in front of Emmit, but there both on your list, so that's just kinda nit picky.

[hrpiii]

How is Alan Page not on that list of Defensive Linemen? Maybe it's reference to "that you have seen" and I don't know your age, so I can see that.

[Kenny Camaro]

Originally Posted by hrpiii

How is Alan Page not on that list of Defensive Linemen? Maybe it's reference to "that you have seen" and I don't know your age, so I can see that.

He said he didn't have any 70s guy's cause he didn't see them, so no Page, Joe Greene, Too Tall Jones,etc.

[hrpiii]

Originally Posted by Kenny Camaro

He said he didn't have any 70s guy's cause he didn't see them, so no Page, Joe Greene, Too Tall Jones,etc.

well if he has Barry Sanders, Emmitt Smith, you would have to have Eric Dickerson. As he was in between those guys.

[Royal Tiger]

Originally Posted by Kenny Camaro

When he does win it, it will be a hard case to not make him the GOAT. Seven appearances, five victories. Most all time victories.most playoff victories. It will just be personal preference or a undefeated Montana or Bradshaw as options, IMO.

If it weren't for the crappy Giants he'd already be a six time champ.

I don't hate the Giants as much as the Eagles or Redskins, but I don't normally care for them much.

[Kenny Camaro]

Originally Posted by hrpiii

well if he has Barry Sanders, Emmitt Smith, you would have to have Eric Dickerson. As he was in between those guys.

Dickerson was a beast, no doubt!

[Dmpsix]

I feel Tom Brady will surpass Joe Montana in most of your average sports bar arguments if he wins another Superbowl.

Tom Brady still has a good 2-3 more appearances before his time is up in the NFL. He has the potential to do things that the NFL will never see again.

[Kenny Camaro]

Originally Posted by Dmpsix

I feel Tom Brady will surpass Joe Montana in most of your average sports bar arguments if he wins another Superbowl.

Tom Brady still has a good 2-3 more appearances before his time is up in the NFL. He has the potential to do things that the NFL will never see again.

I agree..

[Dmpsix]

.... and he did just that.

There are no questioned asked, even Troy Aikman himself said if there ever was an argument as to who was the Greatest QB of all time, Tom Brady tonight ended that.

[rich2342]

He ended it in 14. Now he is just legend.

[Kenny Camaro]

GOAT........ Tom Brady..........

[3 SS's]

but,but, but they went 3-1 without him, but, but but,they went 11-5 with Cassel, but, but he's a system QB LOL
will be updating my Sig Pic soon

GOAT, simple as that !!!!

[Red Chief]

Originally Posted by Dmpsix

I feel Tom Brady will surpass Joe Montana in most of your average sports bar arguments if he wins another Superbowl.

Tom Brady still has a good 2-3 more appearances before his time is up in the NFL. He has the potential to do things that the NFL will never see again.

In 2002, there was one player with quarterback rating over 100 for the season.

In 2016, there were 5.

I don't have the patience to delve deeper into passing stats in 2016 vs. previous eras but I think it's starting to become a joke.

Playing "defense" in the NFL has devolved to basically waiting for A)The QB to throw an incompletion or B)The receiver to drop the ball. At this point a 24 point lead is more like a 10 point lead. That's why Atlanta kept the foot on the gas when they played Green Bay in the NFC Championship. That's why they kept passing when they could have been running out the clock in the superbowl.

[BMR Sales]

Originally Posted by Kenny Camaro

GOAT........ Tom Brady..........

I will finally say that I agree. I am not a Fan of his and I have my own favorite, but TB is the GOAT!